AUGUSTINA MENSAH BAMIDELE v. FRANCIS BAMIDELE
March 5, 2020
COURT OF APPEAL
GHANA
CORAM
- DENNIS ADJEI JA (PRESIDING)
- HENRY A. KWOFIE JA
- ANTHONY OPPONG JA
March 5, 2020
COURT OF APPEAL
GHANA
CORAM
Try asking the following...
ANTHONY OPPONG JA:
The Petitioner/Respondent (hereinafter to be called Petitioner) and the Respondent/Appellant (hereinafter called to be called Respondent) customarily got married in 1990 and subsequently converted it to Ordinance Marriage at the Registrar General’s Office on 9th July, 1996. The marriage lasted for 18 years. On the 28th of June, 2010 the High Court dissolved the marriage based on the evidence that had then been adduced on record. Thereafter, the trial High Court proceeded to gather more evidence in full for purposes of determining the ancillary reliefs relating particularly on property right settlement.
After the full trial of the petition, the High Court settled or decided the property rights of the parties as follows:
a I order the Respondent to convey all his title and interest in the school known as Integrity International with all structures and buildings and the land at Anyaa to the Petitioner
b I order the Respondent to convey all his title and interest in the land at Mallam Junction with all structures and buildings thereon to the petitioner
c I order the Petitioner to convey all her title and interest in the sawmill at Anyaa together with the land, structures and machinery thereon to the Respondent
d I declare that the house at Sowutuom and the land at Ablekuma are commonly owned by the parties and shall be held in equal shares.
The Respondent being dissatisfied with the decision of the High Court pertaining to the property settlement as indicated above appealed to this Court. The relief the Respondent sought from this court on the notice of appeal is for an “order to settle the Integrity International School jointly on both the Petitioner/Respondent and the Respondent/Appellant”
It may be observed that in the Amended Petition, the Petitioner sought a declaration that the matrimonial home at Sowutuom was largely developed by her and same be declared her bona fide property subject to her paying the assessed value of Respondent’s contribution. She again sought declaration that Integrity International school, the land at Ablekuma, the land at Gbawe, land at Malam Junction, school at Anyaa as well as the sawmill at Anyaa are her personal properties. The Respondent also made a case by way of cross petition that the house at Sowutuom, the Integrity International school at Anyaa, sawmill at Gbawe and lands situate at Gbawe and Ablekuma are his personal properties.
In the main, both parties laid claim of exclusive ownership to t
AI Generated Summary
This Ghana Court of Appeal decision, authored by Anthony Oppong JA with Dennis Adjei JA (Presiding) and Henry A. Kwofie JA concurring, addresses ancillary property rights after the dissolution of an 18-year marriage between spouses who married customarily in 1990 and under the Ordinance in 1996. The High Court had allocated Integrity International School and Mallam Junction land to the wife, the Anyaa sawmill to the husband, and declared the Sowutuom house and Ablekuma land jointly owned. On appeal by the husband, the Court of Appeal affirmed the trial court’s factual findings of joint acquisition during the marriage but criticized the unequal allocation without valuation as inequitable. Guided by the Supreme Court’s Mensah v Mensah and Fynn v Fynn precedents, it modified the settlement to direct equal 50–50 sharing of each property, thereby allowing the appeal in part and ensuring balanced division.