Try asking the following...
JUDGMENT
DR. OSEI-HWERE JA
INTRODUCTION
This judgment concerns an appeal against the judgment of the High Court (Lands Division), Accra, dated 29th July, 2022. In that judgment, the plaintiff’s/appellant’s claim against the defendant/respondent herein was dismissed, and judgment was entered in favour of the respondent.
After examining the Record of Appeal, this court has concluded that issues bordering on a conflict of interest in the trial judge's position, and the doctrine of judicial recusal, among other fair trial rules, have taken precedence over the determination of this appeal on its merits.
Judicial independence is not a fanciful notion. It is the cornerstone of every justice system. Its threat extends beyond external influences. Internal influences, such as conflicts of interest and the risk of bias, also undermine the right to a fair hearing. It is settled that court users and society at large must have faith in the court’s ability to resolve disputes fairly and impartially.
A fair hearing is essential to dispute resolution and central to natural justice. Natural justice requires that a person receive a fair and unbiased hearing before any decision that will adversely affect him or her is made. This due process principle applies to both judicial and quasi-judicial forums. Thus, the right to be heard by an independent and impartial court is a constitutional right, and its violation can invalidate an entire proceeding. This judgment turns on these fundamental questions.
BACKGROUND FACTS
The background facts leading to this appeal are that by a writ of summons issued on 5th April 2006, Plaintiff/Appellant (hereinafter called “Appellant”) commenced this action at the High Court against Defendant/Respondent (hereinafter called “Respondent”) seeking the following reliefs:
a. A declaration that Respondent was not entitled and has never been entitled to enter and remain on any part of the portion or portion of an area of land measuring approximately 2,68 acres situate at Alajo, Accra and bounded on the North side by State lands, on the North West by existing road on the South East by a State lands on the South West by State lands which piece and parcel of land is more particularly delineated in an indenture of a lease made between the Lands Commission and Plaintiff for 41 years commencing sometime in 1997, dated the 23rd day of April 2004, stamped and subsequently registered at the Land Title Registry with Certificate No. GA 3000 found in Volum