Try asking the following...
Try asking the following...
December 21, 1979
HIGH COURT
GHANA
CORAM
JUDGMENT OF ROGER KORSAH J.
In this appeal from the judgment of the District Court Grade I, Kumasi, delivered on 13 May 1973, the appellant bases his dissatisfaction on the following grounds:
“(a) the plaintiff failed to discharge the burden on him and therefore the trial magistrate erred in entering judgment for him; and
(b) the whole trial was unsatisfactory as the trial magistrate failed to make any findings on the issues joined between the plaintiff and the defendant.”
Briefly, the plaintiff’s case was that some time in December 1971, or January 1972, there arose a dispute between himself and the defendant, who is his nephew, over the management of the plaintiff’s record shop. In that dispute he threatened to take the shop away from the defendant. Friends and relatives therefore met at the shop and effected a settlement between the parties. The gist of the settlement was that the plaintiff was to allow the defendant to run the shop. It was agreed between the parties that the plaintiff from time to time would go and take stock of the business done, and that the goods (being gramophone records) which the plaintiff was leaving in the shop for the defendant were worth ¢700. He also left stock-in-trade consisting of loudspeakers, changer and an amplifier. No value was placed on these.
The defendant took over the shop and ran it up to April 1972. On 5 April 1972, the plaintiff wrote to the defendant intimating his desire to take stock with him. For three days thereafter the shop was closed and the defendant was nowhere to be found. He had opened [p.817] a shop of his own somewhere else. When the plaintiff eventually gained access to his shops, all that was left therein were eleven records, an amplifier and a changer. His loudspeakers were gone.
The plaintiff on several occasions demanded the return of his goods or their value from the defendant, but the defendant failed to comply with his demands. In the result he commenced proceedings against the defendant claiming as follows:
“The plaintiff’s claim against the defendant is for the sum of ¢818 being the value of the plaintiffs goods which the defendant removed and converted same to his own use without the consent of the plaintiff, which the defendant has refused and still refuses to pay despite repeated demands by the plaintiff.”
The extra ¢118 being the value of the loudspeakers.
At the trial of the action, the plaintiff called as witnesses, three of the persons who were present when the dispute
AI Generated Summary
Roger Korsah J adjudicated an appeal arising from a Kumasi District Court Grade I judgment involving a record shop owner and his nephew who managed the shop after a family-and-friends settlement. The settlement fixed the gramophone records’ value at ¢700; the owner also left loudspeakers, a changer, and an amplifier. When the owner later sought stocktaking in April 1972, the nephew closed the shop and opened his own elsewhere; only eleven records, the changer, and the amplifier remained, and the loudspeakers were missing. Invoking Order 58, r. 18(2) and r. 17, the High Court drew inferences and made findings: it found the loudspeakers were converted and valued at ¢118, and that damages for the records must deduct the eleven left behind. The court refused to apply Quaye v. Mariamu, outlined when retrials are warranted, directed the lower court to ascertain the eleven records’ value within 28 days, suspended final judgment pending certification, and dismissed the appeal.