THE REPUBLIC v. TAHIRU JEBRILA
February 7, 2023
DISTRICT COURT
GHANA
CORAM
- HIS WORSHIP ALHASSAN DRAMANI, ESQ
Areas of Law
- Criminal Law and Procedure
- Evidence Law
February 7, 2023
DISTRICT COURT
GHANA
CORAM
Try asking the following...
JUDGEMENT
The accused person is charged with two counts of Stealing contrary to Section 124 (1) of
the Criminal and Other Offences Act, 1960 (Act 29) and dishonestly receiving contrary to
section 146 of the criminal offences Act, 1960 (Act 29). He pleaded not guilty to both
counts after the charges had been read out and explained to him the Twi language.
FACTS OF THE CASE
The facts of the case as presented by the prosecution are that the complainant, Yaw Yaro
is a driver and resides at Dambai Lakeside whilst the accused Tahiru Jebrila is also a
driver and lives at Dambai Zongo. On 29th March, 2022 at about 9:30am complainant
drove his Man Diesel truck with registration number GW-8241 V to the Alinco fuel station
at Dambai and bought diesel worth GH¢5,600.00 into the truck. After the purchase of the diesel, the complainant proceeded to a mechanic shop at Banka junction, Dambai, for
servicing of the vehicle. The servicing was not completed and so he was made to leave
the truck there for continuation the following day. On 30th March, 2022 at about 7:30am
Complainant went to his truck and detected that all the diesel had been siphoned from
the tank. He reported the case to the Dambai Police for investigation. On 31st March, 2022
whilst investigation was ongoing the police had information that the accused was having
in his possession some jerry cans of diesel which he was offering for sale. The police
proceeded to the house of the accused and met him having in his custody nine jerry cans
of diesel valued at about GH¢5,600.00. When the accused was questioned by the police
as to how he got the diesel, he said it was sold to him by a driver working with a certain
construction company. He requested that police should give him some time to invite the
seller of the diesel for confirmation. He was cautioned to that effect and he maintained
that he will be able to produce the seller. The accused was admitted to bail to enable him
assist the police locate the alleged seller of the diesel but to no avail. Police also requested
the accused to mention the name and location of the construction company for the seller
to be traced but the accused failed to do so. After investigation accused was charged with
the offences and put before this Honourable Court.
The prosecution in proving its case called two (2) witnesses including the investigator
and tendered two (2) exhibits that is the caution and charged statements of the accused
person marked Exh
AI Generated Summary
The District Magistrate, His Worship Alhassan Dramani, tried driver Tahiru Jebrila for two counts—stealing and dishonestly receiving—arising from nine jerry cans of diesel allegedly siphoned from the truck of fellow driver Yaw Yaro in Dambai, Oti. Yaro claimed he bought fuel worth GH¢5,600 at Alinco fuel station before leaving his Man Diesel truck for servicing, and the next morning the fuel was gone. Police found Jebrila with nine jerry cans; he said he purchased them at pump price from a driver at a construction company introduced by his friend, Aliu Mumuni, for personal use. The court underscored the prosecution’s burden to prove identity and dishonest appropriation beyond reasonable doubt, found no direct or compelling circumstantial evidence linking Jebrila to the theft, criticized inconsistencies in fuel quantity and pricing and inadequacies in the investigation, and faulted the incoherent charging theory. The court acquitted Jebrila on both counts and ordered the fuel returned.