THE REPUBLIC v. NGLESHIE ALATA TRADITIONAL COUNCIL & 2 ORS
July 30, 2026
COURT OF APPEAL
GHANA
CORAM
- JENNIFER A. DODOO, J.A (PRESIDING)
- STEPHEN OPPONG, J.A
- FRANKLINA GESILA ADANU, J.A
July 30, 2026
COURT OF APPEAL
GHANA
CORAM
Try asking the following...
JUDGMENT
FRANKLINA GESILA ADANU, J.A:
1.0 General Overview
This appeal arises from the decision of the High Court (Human Rights Division) dated 13/05/2022. Statutory compliance is strictly non-negotiable. In the case of Network Computer System Ltd v. Intelsat Global Sales & Marketing Ltd [2012] 1 SCGLR 218, Atuguba, JSC delivered at 230 as follows:
A court cannot shut its eyes to the violation of a statute as that would be very contrary to its raison d'etre. If a court can suo motu take up the question of illegality even on mere public policy grounds, I do not see how it can fail to take up illegality arising from statutory infraction which has duly come to its notice.
2.1 Applicant/Respondent Case (“Respondent”)
On 14/09/2021, the Respondent caused his lawyers to file a Motion on Notice seeking judicial review by way of certiorari of the decision by the Ngleshie Alata Traditional Council (the Respondent therein) electing Nii Amaah Kwaofio as Acting President, who is the Interested Party and Appellant in this case, on 06/07/2021. The Applicant prayed for a certiorari order to quash the decision on the following grounds:
a. Excess or lack of jurisdiction.
b. Error apparent on the face of the record.
In the affidavit in support of the application filed on 14/09/2021 and supplementary affidavit in reply to the Appellant’s affidavit in opposition filed on 26/11/2021, which were both deposed to by the Respondent himself, Nii Aryeequaye VI Ngleshie Adadentam Mantse, he stated that he was installed as a Sub-Divisional Chief on 02/10/2004. He further deposed that he was gazetted and his name appeared in the National Register of Chiefs after approval on 16/07/2014. In contrast, the Appellant was enstooled ten (10) years after him on 23/10/2010, but he was gazetted, and his name also appeared on the National Register of Chiefs on 16/07/2014. The Respondent also says that he was inducted into the Ngleshie Alata Traditional Council in 2011when it was established. At that time, the Appellant was not a member. According to him, by operation of law, he also became a Divisional Chief when Ngleshie Alata Division was elevated to the status of paramountcy. The Respondent asserted that, like the Appellant, the designation given him was “Mantse (Div Chief)” but in truth and in fact they both held the “Title of Office” of Sub-Divisional Chiefs which changed to Divisional Chiefs after the elevation in 2012. Subseq
AI Generated Summary
The Court of Appeal of Ghana, per Franklina Gesila Adanu, J.A., dismissed the appeal by Nii Amaah Kwaofio (Armaahman Mantse) challenging a High Court order of certiorari that quashed the Ngleshie Alata Traditional Council’s 06/07/2021 election of an 'Acting President'. The Court rejected a preliminary objection that the appeal was moot due to the subsequent enstoolment and gazetting of a new Paramount Chief, finding a live controversy and the need for guidance. Interpreting the Chieftaincy Act, 2008 (Act 759), the Court held there is no statutory office of 'Acting President' for Traditional Councils; when the President is unable to attend or the stool is vacant, the chief next in seniority presides at meetings under section 15(3). The 06/07/2021 meeting was convened by registrars, contrary to section 15(1), and improperly proceeded to elections. The Court emphasised that mandatory statutory procedures must be followed, and estoppel cannot validate illegality. Seniority for presiding is determined by valid enstoolment/customary hierarchy, not gazette dates. Judges Jennifer A. Dodoo, J.A. (Presiding) and Stephen Oppong, J.A. concurred.