THE REPUBLIC v. GRACE KPESESE & ANOTHER
June 15, 2023
DISTRICT COURT
GHANA
CORAM
- HIS WORSHIP NELSON DELASI AWUKU DISTRICT MAGISTRATE
Areas of Law
- Criminal Law and Procedure
- Evidence Law
June 15, 2023
DISTRICT COURT
GHANA
CORAM
Try asking the following...
BACKGROUND
The accused persons were arraigned before this Court on 26th April, 2022 on charges of
Conspiracy to commit crime to wit assault, Assault and Causing Harm contrary to
Sections 23(1), 84 and 69 of the Criminal Offences Act, 1960 (Act 29).
BRIEF FACTS
The facts as read by Prosecution stated that the complainant Korsi Dotsey age 57 years
old is the brother of the second accused Robert Dotsey 47 years old. The first accused
Grace Kpesese is a trader and the wife of the second accused.
The Prosecution stated that on 29th November, 2021 at about 11:00am, the complainant
visited his compound and while standing under a coconut tree, A1 and A2 without any
provocation attacked him with sticks and assaulted him till he fell unconscious on the
ground.
The Prosecution stated that A1 in the cause of the attack hit the head of the complainant
with a stick which resulted in an injury that caused the complainant to be rushed to the
hospital for treatment.
The prosecution stated that the complainant later reported the matter to the police and
the accused persons were arrested.
The prosecution stated that A1 admitted the offence in her investigation caution
statement to the police but A2 denied his involvement. Both accused persons were
charged with the offences and arraigned before the court.
PLEA OF ACCUSED PERSONS
A2 pleaded not guilty to the offences when the charges and particulars were read and
interpreted to him. A plea of not guilty was entered for A1 after her explanations. Both
accused persons were admitted to bail.
Witness statements of witnesses of prosecution together with charge statements and
investigation caution statements of the accused persons were filed by the prosecution
together with a medical report of complainant and served on the accused persons for
trial.
THE CASE OF PROSECUTION
The prosecution relied on the evidence of the complainant as his first witness and called
as additional witnesses Afi Dotsey as PW2 and the police investigator D/Inspector Bright
Quarshie as PW3.
In his evidence to the Court, the complainant, first prosecution witness stated that, he is
a farmer and a native of Vume but currently resides in Afife and goes to farm at Vume.
PW1 stated that on the 29th of November, 2021 at about 8:00am he was on his compound
on a normal visit and realized someone had put a trip of sand on his portion of the land.
PW1 stated further that whiles standing under a coconut tree on the compound, A2 came
AI Generated Summary
At the District Magistrate Court, His Worship Nelson Delasi Awuku tried Grace Kpesese and her husband Robert Dotsey on charges of conspiracy, assault and causing harm under Act 29, arising from an incident on 29 November 2021 involving Robert’s brother, complainant Korsi Dotsey. The prosecution presented Korsi (PW1), Afi Dotsey (PW2), and D/Inspector Bright Quarshie (PW3), tendering caution and charge statements, medical reports, and photographs. PW1 said Robert struck him from behind; PW2, arriving after cries for help, saw both accused beating Korsi. Grace admitted striking Korsi with firewood but asserted self‑defence, alleging Korsi broke into their kitchen, destroyed items, and assaulted her; PW3 under cross confirmed damage and that Grace received a medical form. Reviewing the burden of proof, conspiracy law, and self‑defence under Section 37, the court found no evidence of prior agreement, noted PW2 was not privy to the entire incident, and faulted the failure to call neutral eyewitnesses. Concluding the prosecution had not proven the charges beyond reasonable doubt, the court acquitted and discharged both accused.