Try asking the following...
Try asking the following...
June 4, 2024
HIGH COURT
GHANA
CORAM
Before me is an application of the 2nd Defendant/Applicant filed on 5th April, 2024 praying this Court for an order that 2nd Defendant ceases to be a party in this suit. This application is being brought under Order 4 Rule 5(a) of the High Court Civil Procedure Rules, C.I.47, and same is being opposed by Counsel for the Plaintiff/Respondent in an Affidavit in Opposition filed on 19th April, 2024. The Plaintiff and 2nd Defendant’s Counsel opted to file their written submissions in respect of this application and an order was made by the Court for the parties to do so.
The Court notes that all lawyers have complied with this order and Counsel for the 2nd Defendant filed her submission on 23rd May, 2024. Counsel for the Plaintiff filed his on 24th May, 2024 whilst Counsel for the 1st Defendant also filed his on 3rd June, 2024 in which he is not opposed to the current application even though 1 st Defendant did not filed an affidavit responding to the said motion. The Court has read these written submissions by the parties and I do not intend to adjourn any further, and I will therefore proceed to deliver a bench ruling. I do appreciate the industry put in by all Counsel in respect of this motion.
Briefly the background to this application is that, the Plaintiff in its Amended Writ of Summons and Statement of Claim filed on 23rd January, 2024 sought the reliefs on its endorsement to the Writ against the Plaintiff and Defendants jointly and severally. The 1 st Defendant entered appearance and filed its Statement of Defence and Counterclaim on 27th March, 2024. The 2nd Defendant also entered appearance and filed its Statement of Defence on 23rd February, 2024. Subsequent to these filings, the 2nd Defendant filed this application under Order 5(2a) of C.I.47 which states as follows:
At any stage of proceedings, the Court may on such terms as it thinks just either on its motion or on application
“(a) Order any person who has been improperly or unnecessarily made a party or who for any reason is no longer a party or a necessary party to cease to be a party”.
The 2nd Defendant’s case is that it is not a party to the agreement between the 1 st Defendant and the Plaintiff, and the Insurance Policy was not made on behalf of the Plaintiff, and therefore it is not a necessary party to this suit.
This position is supported by the 1st Defendant who is the 2nd Defendant insured. The Plaintiff also averred that by the agreement between the
AI Generated Summary
Justice Sheila Minta of the High Court delivered a bench ruling on a motion by the 2nd Defendant, the insurer of the 1st Defendant, seeking to cease being a party to the suit under the High Court Civil Procedure Rules, C.I.47. The Plaintiff’s amended writ seeks reliefs against the 1st and 2nd Defendants jointly and severally, alleging losses to goods stored in the 1st Defendant’s facility for which insurance coverage was required. The 2nd Defendant argued it was not party to the underlying agreement and that the insurance was not made on behalf of the Plaintiff; the 1st Defendant supported this position. The Plaintiff contended it is a third-party beneficiary able to recover under the policy. The Court held that the 2nd Defendant’s accrual-of-cause-of-action argument is a matter of defence to be addressed under Orders 11 and 33, not by removing the insurer under Order 5(2a), and dismissed the application without costs.