SOCIETE GENERAL GHANA LTD vs. JT COMMERCIALS LTD
November 26, 2024
HIGH COURT
GHANA
CORAM
- MAVIS ANDOH J (MRS).
Areas of Law
- Banking and Finance Law
- Evidence Law
November 26, 2024
HIGH COURT
GHANA
CORAM
Try asking the following...
The Plaintiff on 6th October 2020, caused to be issued out of the Registry of this Court, a Writ of Summons and Statement of Claim against the Defendant for the following reliefs;
The brief facts that have snowballed into this action are given as follows. The Plaintiff is a Bank which carries its business at its Faanofaa Branch in Accra and elsewhere in Ghana with the Defendant as one of its customers at the said branch. In January 2016, the Plaintiff allowed the Defendant to overdraw its account to the tune of GH¢42,565.48. This was after the Defendant had on or about the 8th of January 2016, issued a cheque in the sum of GH¢57,773.68 in favor of Accra Brewery Limited, and drawn on its account with the Plaintiff. Even though the Defendant did not have enough funds in its said account to meet the face value of the cheque, the Plaintiff nonetheless honored the cheque.
According to the Plaintiff, the Defendant has failed or neglected to reimburse the Plaintiff for the overdrawn account, despite repeated demands made on it and as of 30th June 2020, the Defendant was indebted to Plaintiff to the tune of GH¢78,681,82 made up of the money overdrawn by the Defendant and accrued interest.
The Plaintiff therefore sued the Defendant for the reliefs endorsed on the Writ of Summons and accompanying Statement of Claim.
When the Defendant was served with the Writ via substituted service, it entered an appearance to the action through its Counsel on 2nd March 2021and on 23rd March 2021, filed a 20-paragraphed Statement of Defence and Counterclaim, denying each and every averments made by Plaintiff in its Statement of Claim, partly admitting some.
According to the Defendant, it neither held any standing order nor signed a mandate that gave Plaintiff the permission to take funds from Defendant's accounts to grant or give top-ups on Defendant's cheque issued to third parties as alleged by Plaintiff. Contrary to the allega
AI Generated Summary
This High Court commercial dispute between Societe Generale Ghana and its customer J.T Commercials Limited concerns recovery of funds after the bank honored a cheque to Accra Brewery Limited despite insufficient funds. The court found that J.T Commercials issued cheque No.000140 for GH a257,773.68 on 8 January 2016 and, relying on a longstanding banking relationship, the bank allowed an overdraft of GH a242,565.48 to honor it. Applying Ghanaian evidentiary standards, the court credited documentary exhibits and testimony over bare denials and determined the account was not fully funded at the time. Cross-examination revealed lodgments reducing the shortfall, making the banks higher claim of GH a278,681.82 untenable. The court resolved Issues 13 for the bank and Issues 45 for the customer, dismissed the counterclaim as moot, and entered judgment for Societe Generale Ghana to recover GH a228,735.76 with interest at the banks lending rate, plus GH a210,000 costs.