ROYAL MAGMA GHANA LTD. v. COMEXAS LTD.
October 15, 2024
HIGH COURT, COMMERCIAL DIVISION (COURT 1)
GHANA
CORAM
- HER LADYSHIP JUSTICE SHEILA MINTA
Areas of Law
- Contract Law
- Evidence Law
October 15, 2024
HIGH COURT, COMMERCIAL DIVISION (COURT 1)
GHANA
CORAM
Try asking the following...
The Plaintiff is a company registered under the laws of the Republic of Ghana. The Defendant is also a company engaged in the business of clearing and freight forwarding. On 10th October, 2018, the parties entered into negotiations for the rental of Plaintiff’s container handler, for the purposes of offloading shipping containers of Defendant. The parties had an understanding that the arrangement between them would run for a period of three (3) months commencing from October 2018 to December 2018. However, in the same month of October 2018, just 2 weeks into the trial phase and after the completion of eighty-six (86) moves by the Plaintiff the Defendant decided not to continue with the said arrangement. Plaintiff then invoiced Defendant for US$6,146.15 inclusive of VAT which was challenged by the Defendant on the ground that the basis of the calculation of the 86 moves was wrong. Plaintiff’s response is that the Defendant having unilaterally terminated the agreement entitled Plaintiff to revert to its usual charges for short term rentals hence the figure of US$6,146.15 demanded is what ought to be paid and based on the GPHA short term rate.
The Defendant challenging the said figure of US$6,146.15 refused to pay same and issued a cheque covering eight-six (86) moves at the rate of US$10 per move. This said cheque was refused by the Plaintiff and caused its lawyers to issue a Writ of Summons and a corresponding Statement of Claim on the 11th of November, 2022 against the Defendant for the following reliefs:-
a)An order directed at the Defendant to pay the amounts owed and outstanding to the Plaintiff in the sum of US$6,146.15 inclusive of VAT payable in Ghana Cedis at the prevailing exchange rate.
b)An order directed at Defendant to pay interest on the outstanding amount in the sum of US$6,146.15 inclusive of VAT payable in Ghana Cedis at the prevailing exchange rate.
c)Costs.
d)Legal fees.
The Defendant in response to Plaintiff’s Writ of Summons and Statement of Claim, filed a Statement of Defence on the 16th of January, 2023.
Plaintiff in its Witness Statement filed on 13th February, 2024 contended that the rental arrangement entered into between the parties was based on the following terms:
•That the Container Handler was rented out based on at least 300 TEUS per month.
•That the rental period was to be for an i
AI Generated Summary
This High Court judgment by Justice Sheila Minta concerns a dispute between a Ghanaian equipment owner and a freight forwarding company over a three‑month trial rental of a container handler beginning October 10, 2018. Two weeks into the trial and after 86 moves, the freight forwarder stopped the arrangement. The equipment owner invoiced US$6,146.15, claiming GPHA short‑term rates applied because the forwarder unilaterally terminated. The forwarder contested the invoice and tendered payment based on US$10 per move, asserting an agreed US$9 discounted rate. The court found a binding trial‑period agreement and held unilateral termination without an express clause was a breach. However, the owner failed to prove the invoiced GPHA rate. Applying evidentiary burdens and avoiding conjecture, the court used an equitable average (US$11.5 per move) and reduced damages by 40% for mitigation, awarding US$3,560.4 without interest or costs.