REYSONS GHANA LTD. v. PALM GROVE LTD. & ANOR
November 6, 2024
HIGH COURT, COMMERCIAL DIVISION (COURT 1)
GHANA
CORAM
- HER LADYSHIP JUSTICE SHEILA MINTA
Areas of Law
- Contract Law
- Civil Procedure
November 6, 2024
HIGH COURT, COMMERCIAL DIVISION (COURT 1)
GHANA
CORAM
Try asking the following...
In this case the Plaintiff, Reysons Ghana Limited, suing per its lawful Attorney Experts Consults Limited, issued a Writ of Summons against the Defendants on 21st January, 2019 for the refund of some moneys paid to the Defendants among others sometime in 2011 as deposit for the sale of land at Ring Road Central. The basis of this claim according to the Plaintiff is founded on the Contract of Sale executed between Palm Grove Estate Limited and Reysons Homes Limited for the sale of land which did not happen hence a demand for a refund, interest thereon and costs. Plaintiff avers that at the time of the said arrangement 2nd Defendant was a director of the 1st Defendant company and payments were made into 2nd Defendant’s accounts. 1st Defendant denied ever receiving any amount from the Plaintiff in respect of any transaction and the 2nd Defendant says that Palm Grove Limited is not known to her and therefore not entitled to its claim.
According to the Plaintiff, the Defendants offered to it a parcel of land situate at Ring Road Central for sale sometime in 2011 for which a contract of sale was executed between the Plaintiff and the 1st Defendant and in support of this tendered as Exhibit “B” (contract of sale dated November 2011). That the consideration for the said property was agreed at US$2,100,000.00 for which an advance deposit of US$100,000.00 was paid into 2nd Defendant’s and tendered Exhibit “C” (Statement of Account of Reysons (Gh) Ltd. dated 23rd March, 2012). The Plaintiff says that the Defendants failed to perform their side of the agreement and also failed to refund the payments made after several demands hence the current suit filed by Plaintiff’s Lawful Attorney on 21st January, 2019. Plaintiff tendered Exhibit “A” Power of Attorney dated 23rd October, 2018 appointing Expert Consult Limited.
In this suit its claims are as follows:-
i.Recovery of the amount of US$100,000.00 being the cumulative indebtedness of Defendants to Plaintiff in respect of part payment of piece of land situated at Ring Road Central, Accra.
ii.Interest on the aforesaid sum at the prevailing commercial bank rate from November 2011 until date final of payment.
iii.Costs.
1st Defendant denies entering into any agreement with the Plaintiff and says it does not owe Plaintiff and no money was ever received from the Plaintiff by it in respect of any Contract of Sale. It
AI Generated Summary
Reysons Ghana Limited, acting through its lawful attorney Experts Consults Limited, sued Palm Grove Limited and Agnes Ackon over a failed 2011 land sale at Ring Road Central in Accra. Relying on a November 2011 contract of sale (Exhibit B) and a bank statement evidencing a US$100,000 deposit into Agnes Ackon’s account (Exhibit C), the plaintiff sought a refund, interest, and costs. Palm Grove Limited denied any agreement or receipt of funds, and both defendants asserted the claim was time-barred. Justice Sheila Minta first addressed limitation, holding the cause of action accrued in November 2011 and, absent acknowledgment of debt, became time-barred after November 2017 under Section 4 of the Limitation Act 1972. The court also held the named plaintiff lacked capacity and privity because the contract was between Reysons Homes Limited and Palm Grove Estate Limited, emphasizing the sanctity of contracts and the court’s inability to amend contractual parties. Finding the writ invalid, the court dismissed the claim and awarded costs of GHS 20,000 each to Palm Grove Limited and Agnes Ackon.