Try asking the following...
Try asking the following...
March 27, 1991
HIGH COURT
GHANA
CORAM
By an oral application before this honourable court on 20 March 1991 the defendants' counsel sought leave of the court to exercise an option under the plaintiff's amended indorsement on his original writ of summons filed together with a statement of claim on 25 April 1985. It would be recalled that this court granted the plaintiff leave to amend on 15 January 1991, by which a third additional relief was added to the said writ of summons to read:
"(3) Alternatively the refund of the sum of ¢19,000 plus interest at the current bank rate, and the return of 86 bags of cement and 2,500 pieces of cement blocks or their open market value at the date of judgment."
The defendants' counsel argued that the third additional relief should be interpreted by the court as granting the defendants with a clear option to select or choose from the plaintiff's writ of summons which of the three reliefs they would like to give to the plaintiff for his alleged losses under the contract of sale of 30 June 1976. That being the case, the defendants would like to exercise that option by settling the case on the third alternative relief.
The issue for the court to decide is whether by his amended indorsement on the writ of summons by which an alternative relief was [p.32] added to the two previous reliefs sought against the defendants, the plaintiff presented the defendants with a clear option the exercise of which clearly foreclosed the two other previous remedies sought by the plaintiff against the defendants.
Perhaps it would be appropriate to state the reliefs on the plaintiff's writ of summons in their entirety in order to clarify the situation. The three reliefs of the plaintiff are:
"(1) An order for the specific performance of the contract entered into between the plaintiff and the defendants in respect of the premises on plot No. G10 (SH 3), Nsukwao, Koforidua.
(2) Perpetual injunction restraining the defendants, their servants or agents from interfering with the plaintiff’s possession thereof or transferring or in any manner alienating the said property to a third party.
(3) Alternatively, the refund of the sum of ¢19,000 plus interest at the current bank rate, and the return of 86 bags of cement and 2,500 pieces of cement blocks or their open market value at the date of judgment."
It is of interest to remember that the third alternative amended relief was granted by this court on 15 January 1991 when evidence had already started and the plaintiff was about to clo
AI Generated Summary
On 20 March 1991, in the High Court presided over by EBIASAH J, the defendants counsel made an oral application seeking leave to exercise an option purportedly created by the plaintiffs amended indorsement on the writ. The plaintiff had earlier, on 15 January 1991, obtained leave to add a third alternative remedy to his original claims for specific performance and a perpetual injunction concerning premises on plot No. G10 (SH 3), Nsukwao, Koforidua. The added alternative sought refund of a219,000 with bank-rate interest and the return of building materials or their market value. Defendants asked to settle the case by choosing that alternative. The court framed the issue as whether the plaintiffs alternative relief conferred an election on defendants. Explaining alternative in pleadings, the court held the options were for the courts choice among equitable and money reliefs, not for defendants. Considering the advanced stage of trial, the court refused the application without costs, concluding Application refused.