NURU ADAM v FRANK CALCULUS YEBOAH & ANOR
October 15, 2024
HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE, COMMERCIAL COURT “8” LAW COURT COMPLEX
GHANA
CORAM
- JUSTICE MAVIS AKUA ANDOH
Areas of Law
- Civil Procedure
- Evidence Law
October 15, 2024
HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE, COMMERCIAL COURT “8” LAW COURT COMPLEX
GHANA
CORAM
Try asking the following...
This is an interpleader action involving the Claimant and the Plaintiff/ Judgment Creditor herein. In this delivery, the Claimant will still be referred to as the Claimant and the Plaintiff/Judgment Creditor will be referred to as the Plaintiff/Judgment/Creditor. The Defendant/Judgment Debtor will also be referred to as the Defendant/Judgment Debtor.
The Plaintiff/Judgment Creditor on 29th June 2016, issued out of the Registry of the Court, a Writ of Summons and Statement of Claim against the Defendant/Judgment Debtor for the following reliefs;
a) An order for payment of the sum of GH¢2,713,672.65 to the Plaintiff by the Defendant.
b) A further order for payment of interest on the sum of money or on monies realized from each transaction aforesaid from the period it fell due and owing to the Plaintiff.
c) Damages for breach of Contract.
d) Cost inclusive of Solicitor’s fees.
The matter went through a full trial after which, this Court differently constituted on 5th November 2020 entered Judgment in favour of the Plaintiff/Judgment Creditor.
After obtaining judgment in 2020, and in pursuit of enforcing same to enjoy the fruits of his judgment, the Plaintiff/Judgment Creditor commenced the execution process by filing the entry of judgment on 9th December 2020 and same was served on the Defendant/ Judgment Debtor on 11th December 2020, to recover the total amount of Seven Million, Two hundred and Eighty Two Thousand, Nine Hundred and Forty One Ghana Cedis, Sixty Five Ghana Pesewas (GHC7, 282, 941.65) from the Defendant/Judgment Debtor.
To enforce the judgment, the Plaintiff/ Judgment Creditor caused execution to be levied on the Defendant/ Judgment Debtor’s immovable property situate, lying and being at Macetown Street, 4 Ayikai Doblo, Judah, near Amasaman in the Greater Accra Region of the Republic of Ghana.
Again, this Court differently constituted instructed Mark Atiemo of Prestige properties Accra, to conduct a valuation on the said property in order to ascertain its market value. The valuation was accordingly done and the open market value of the property was GHS3, 418, 600.00, while the forced sale value was GH¢2,393.000.00.
When the said property above described was attached in execution of the judgment debt, a Claimant Irene Kumi, filed an Interpleader Notice on the 20th of May 2022, pursuant to Order 44 rule (12) of the High Court Civil (Procedure) Rules 2004, C.I. 47 claiming to be the owner of the attached property.
According to the
AI Generated Summary
The Commercial Court 8 of the High Court in Accra resolved an interpleader dispute initiated by Irene Kumi after a property at Macetown Street, 4 Ayikai Doblo, Judah, near Amasaman was attached in execution of a judgment obtained in 2020 against the Defendant/Judgment Debtor. Following valuation by Mark Atiemo of Prestige Properties (open market GHS3,418,600; forced sale GH2,393,000), Kumi claimed bona fide purchase in 2016 backed by receipts, a Lands Commission search, Lands Valuation Board processing, and a Deed of Conveyance. The Plaintiff/Judgment Creditor disputed, citing inconsistencies: Exhibit Es date predating alleged payments, consideration of GH50,000 rather than GH2,300,000, and missing lessor consent under the lease. Applying the Evidence Act275 burden-of-proof rules and Order 44 of C.I. 47, the court summarily determined the interpleader, rejected Kumis claim as implausible and possibly collusive, ordered execution to proceed, set a hearing to fix the reserved price, and awarded GH10,000 costs against Kumi.