MUSAH DAUDA ALSO KNOWN AS MUSA BASHIRU v TAMALE MOTOR CYCLE REPAIRERS’ ASSOCIATION PER ITS EXECUTIVES MUTARU AND AWAL
April 29, 2024
HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE
GHANA
CORAM
- Justice Eric Ansah Ankomah
Areas of Law
- Property and Real Estate Law
April 29, 2024
HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE
GHANA
CORAM
Try asking the following...
Declaration that plaintiff is the owner of Plot No.64 Katariga Residential Area Block A which is bounded to the north by Plot Nos. 61, 63 and 59 to the West by access route and to the East by the Main Katariga road.
a. An order of mandatory injunction on the defendant to remove the structure it has erected on Plaintiff's above plot without his consent.
b. An order of perpetual injunction restraining the Defendant, its agents, servant, assigns, or persons claiming through it from interfering in whatever manner with the Plaintiff's possession, ownership and use of Plot No. 64, Katariga Residential Area Block A.
c. Recovery of possession.
d. Damages against the Defendant for trespass to the land and causing damage to the land.
e. Cost including legal fees.
1. The writ of summons was accompanied by motion for interim injunction restraining the defendant from developing the disputed land or dealing with it in any way until the final determination of the suit.
2. The court differently constituted granted the application for a limited period of ten days. The application was repeated on notice on 7/09/2020 and on 28th September, 2020, the court granted the interlocutory application for injunction restraining the defendant, its executives, assigns and workmen from developing the land in dispute.
3. On 17th March 2021, the court set down the issues as well as the additional issues for trial and made an order for the parties to file survey instructions to enable the Regional Surveyor of the Survey and Mapping Division of Lands Commission, Tamale to determine whether Plot No. 53A Katariga Residential Area is the same plot described as Plot 64 Katariga Residential Area Block A by the plaintiff. The surveyor was to present a comprehensive report to the court.
4. On 20th January, 2022, the Regional Surveyor presented its report to the court. None of the parties called the surveyor for cross examination. In the course of this judgment I will come back to the survey report and deal with it in detail.
5. I must place on record that the defendant did not file counterclaim in this action. As at the time of writing this judgment counsel for the defendant had not filed his written address though served with a copy of the proceedings and I deem it as waived. I shal
AI Generated Summary
This High Court land dispute in Tamale was decided by Justice Eric Ansah Ankomah. Musah Dauda sought a declaration of ownership and related reliefs over Plot No. 64, Katariga Residential Area Block A, claiming purchase from Alhassan Musah (PW1) and relying on an allocation paper (Exhibit B) and a statutory declaration (Exhibit C). The Tamale Motor Cycle Mechanics Association contested, asserting long-standing acquisition of Plot No. 53A, re-demarcation by the Zoonaa into 53A and 53B, and acts of possession including signposts and a pavilion. The court found Exhibit B inconsistent with the claimed Block ‘A’ description and Exhibit C self-serving and of questionable authenticity; PW1’s credibility was undermined by inconsistencies and failure to produce original documents. Visible acts of possession defeated any claim of bona fide purchase without notice. The survey report was rejected as incompetent. Applying the Evidence Act burdens, the court held the plaintiff failed to prove title, dismissed all reliefs, and awarded GHc 10,000 costs against him.