KWAKU ANSAH- ASARE v ABDUL RAHMAN LARBI
March 27, 2024
HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE (COMMERCIAL DIVISION)
GHANA
CORAM
- NANA YAW GYAMFI FRIMPONG, J.
Areas of Law
- Property and Real Estate Law
- Contract Law
March 27, 2024
HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE (COMMERCIAL DIVISION)
GHANA
CORAM
Try asking the following...
Plaintiff instituted the instant action against the Defendant and by his amended statement of claim endorsed his writ for the following reliefs:
(a) A declaration that the transaction concerning the sale of Defendant's ancestral family land between the Defendant acting for and on behalf of his siblings, on the one hand, and Plaintiff, on the other hand, was by customary law.
(b) A further declaration that the land covers an area approximately 5.91 acres or 2.39 hectares, more or less, and can be identified by the under listed Survey Pillars more particularly delineated on the Site Plan covering the land: SGEA264/08/27; SGEA264/08/28; SGE A264/08/28A; SGEA264/08/29; SGEA 264/08/30;SGEA264/08/31;SGEA264/08/32;SGEA264/08/33;SGEA264/08/34 and SGEA 264/08/35
(c) An order for the appointment of the Regional Surveyor, Survey Department, Koforidua, to inspect the Site and supervise the alienation of land in dispute as delineated on the Site Plan to Plaintiff.
(d) A further order that the vendor family shall execute a conveyance in favour of Plaintiff forthwith or, in default thereof, an order directing the Registrar of this Honourable Court to represent the vendor family, to execute the conveyance with the Plaintiff.
(e) General damages for the economic trees Defendant have felled on the land to make charcoal without Plaintiff's knowledge, concurrence and consent.
(f) An account of income which has come into Defendant's hands from sale of farm produce and the payment of Plaintiff's share thereof to Plaintiff with interest on the accrued sums.
(g) An order that Defendant shall quit from the land forthwith.
The Defendant filed a 11-paragraph statement of defence to the action on 17th July, 2020 and counterclaimed against the Plaintiff for the following reliefs:
a. An order for the Defendant to refund to the Plaintiff the GH¢16,000.00 Plaintiff paid to the Defendant as part payment of the purchase price of the land or in the alternative:
b. An order compelling the Plaintiff to pay GH¢44,000.00 being the outstanding balance of the purchase price of the land to the Defendant together with interest at the current commercial Bank interest rate from 2008 till date of final payment.
At the close of pleadings, Plaintiff filed an Application for Directions and set out the following issues for the consideration by the Court as follows:
*a Whether or not the Plaintiff acquired the 5.91 acre-l
AI Generated Summary
Justice Nana Yaw Gyamfi Frimpong of the High Court adjudicated a dispute arising from an oral sale of land between Lawyer Kwaku Ansa-Asare, founder of MountCrest University, and Abdul Rahman Larbi of the Kwao Badu Family at Larteh-Akuapem. The land at Abeten/Yeramah was measured at roughly 5.91 acres after demarcation. Ansa-Asare paid GH a216,000 and later demanded vacant possession and conveyance; Larbi insisted the agreed total price was GH a260,000 (GH a210,000 per acre/GH a22,500 per plot), leaving GH a244,000 outstanding. The Court found the land was family property, that negotiations involved the family head and a member, and that the plaintiffs GH a2800-per-plot theory was mathematically inconsistent and uncorroborated, while the defendants version was corroborated. It dismissed the plaintiffs claims, accepted the defendants price, entered judgment on the counterclaim, and, following the parties pre-delivery agreement, ordered a refund of GH a216,000 without interest and no costs.