Try asking the following...
JUDGMENT
MENSAH-HOMIAH, JA
INTRODUCTION
This is an appeal against the Ruling of the High Court, Commercial Division, Accra, delivered on 4 November 2025 in which the court refused to set aside its earlier ruling/order for the examination of witnesses in a matter pending before a foreign court (United States District Court for the Southern District of New York). The Respondents/Applicants/Appellants, being dissatisfied with this ruling, have brought the instant appeal on several grounds as set out in their notice of appeal filed on 7 November 2025.
In this delivery, the Respondents/Applicants/Appellants and the Applicant/Respondent/ Respondent will be referred to as Appellants and Respondent, respectively.
BACKGROUND FACTS
By an originating motion ex parte, filed on 28 August 2025, Kimathi Kuenyehia (suing as authorised representative of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York), sought the following reliefs from the High Court (Commercial Division), Accra:
a. An order for Activa International Insurance Company (Ghana) Limited (“Activa”); and Simon Nartey, David Commey Tetteh and Benjamin Yamoah (“the Witnesses”) to produce for copying and inspection the documents specified in exhibit 3 of the Letter of Request;
b. An order for Activa and the Witnesses to respond to the interrogatories specified in Exhibit 4 of the Letter of Request;
c. An order for Activa and the Witnesses to be orally examined under oath before an Examiner of the Court in the manner stipulated in sections E and F of the Letter of Request; and
d. An order of the Court for examination, the deposition taken in pursuance of the Order for examination including responses to interrogatories, and all documents received from Activa and the Witnesses to be sent to the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York.
Per the Letter of Request/Rogatory, the assistance sought by the US District Court from the appropriate judicial authority in the Republic of Ghana was deemed necessary in the interests of justice in a substantive case pending before it, titled:
Civil Action No. 1.24-cv-05298-MMG Newmont Corporation and Newmont Ghana Gold Limited vs. American International Group UK Limited & Others.
On 24 September 2025, the Court below after hearing counsel for the Applicant therein made the following orders:
1. *Activa International Insurance Company (Ghana) Limited (“Activa”) and the identified witnesses, namely Simon Narte