Try asking the following...
Forster JA. Kaguin Enterprises Ltd and Umarco are both companies incorporated under the laws of Ghana. In or about July 1989, Kaguin (hereinafter called the respondents) imported some 4,659,014 metric tonnes of rice from Cargill International, a company registered. In Antigua. When the rice arrived in Ghana the whole lot was received by Umarco (hereinafter referred to as the appellants) and stored in the custom bonded warehouse at Tema. There was evidence that Umarco group of companies worked with Cargill International worldwide.
The appellants subsequently released only 700 metric tonnes (14,000 bags) of the rice to the respondents. The respO[1]dents therefore sued out a writ against the appellants at the High Court, Accra. They claimed the following reliefs:
" (1) A declaration that the plaintiff is the owner consignee of 4,659,014 metric tonnes of rice imported from Cargill International, SA Antigua in or about July 1989.
(2) An order upon the defendant to account to the plaintiff for the 4,6591014 metric tonnes of rice or any portion of the said consignment disposed of by the defendants.
(3) Another order upon the defendants to pay general damages for conversion."
The appellants denied by their statement of defence that they were liable to the respondents for any of the reliefs sought. On 24 October 1997, the court presided over by Sapong JA (sitting as an additional High Court judge) gave judgment for the respondents for all the reliefs claimed. An appeal to this court by the appellants was lodged on 28 October 1997. Meanwhile on 27 October 1997 the respondents had filed a motion for review of the judgment. Then on 14 October 1997 Sapong J A heard and granted the respondents' motion for review of the very judgment against which an appeal had been filed by the appellants. It might not be necessary to revisit this issue.
The issues raised in the grounds of appeal were fully treated by both counsel in their respective written submissions. In this judgment, I shall thus confine myself to the issues as argued in the written submissions. The first and probably the pivotal issue was whether the respondents were the owners or consignees for the 4,659,014 metric tonnes of rice. In his judgment the trial judge, having considered the import of a bill of lading (exhibit 14) covering the rice, found that the respondents were not described therein as consignees, but "notify address". I think he should have been more