FUSENI MOHAMMED v. ABDULAI YAYA AND T.T.YAYA
June 21, 2023
DISTRICT COURT
GHANA
CORAM
- HER WORSHIP JOSEPHINE SARFO (MRS
Areas of Law
- Tort Law
- Property and Real Estate Law
June 21, 2023
DISTRICT COURT
GHANA
CORAM
Try asking the following...
The Plaintiff in a writ issued on 10/11/2021 sought the following reliefs:
a. An amount of GHC 450.00 being the cost of 150 cement blocks Defendants
destroyed on his site.
b. Any order (s) the Court may deem fit.
Plaintiff in the statement of claimed averred that on 9th November, 2021, he
purchased 150 pieces of cement blocks from Mahazu Amidu Enterprise, New Tafo-
Akim for use on his site at Akyem Maase. That as part of the purchasing policy of
the Enterprise, the cement blocks were conveyed to his site; upon arrival when the
cement blocks were being offloaded unto the site from the vehicle, the Defendants
out of nowhere, appeared and begun destroying the blocks. When he inquired from
the Defendants the reason for their act, the Defendants told him that they were
destroying the blocks to prevent him from continuing with the construction of his
building. According to the Plaintiff, all the 150 blocks of cement were destroyed by
the Defendants without any show of remorse on their part.
The Defendants have resisted the claim of the Plaintiff and instead set out a cross
action in the nature of a counterclaim for the following reliefs:
a. Declaration of title and recovery of possession of all that piece or parcel of
land situate, lying and being at Akyem – Maase and bounded as follows: On
one side lies the Akyem Maase and Anyinasin Motor Road, on one side lies
the property of Seibu Ismaila, on one side lies the property of Kwaku Biribi
and on the other side lies the big gutter.
b. Perpetual injunction restraining Plaintiff, his agents, assigns, privies, etc, from
interfering with the land.
c. Punitive cost.
The Defendants in their statement of defence averred that the Plaintiff was
offloading the cement blocks unto their land; beside a store building of their Senior
brother by name Inusah Ismaila. According to them, the land has been their family
land for years now; it belonged to their father by name Yahaya Bassari and thus the
Plaintiff had no right to offload the cement blocks on it. The Defendants averred that
the action of the Plaintiff in offloading the cement blocks on their land was an act
on his part to test the waters as to how they were going to react in the event that he
went on with the development of the land. The Defendants averred that the action of
the Plaintiff amounts to trespass and nuisance thus they asked the driver of the truck
and Plaintiff to desist from offloading the blocks on the land however the Pla
AI Generated Summary
Her Worship Josephine Sarfo (Mrs) adjudicated a dispute at Akyem Maase concerning cement blocks offloaded for construction. The plaintiff purchased 150 blocks from Mahazu Amidu Enterprise; during offloading, the defendants appeared and destroyed blocks, claiming the site was their family land near their brother Inusah Ismaila’s store. They counterclaimed for title, possession and injunction. The plaintiff contended the blocks were on a public footpath accessing his land. In the absence of a plan, the court visited the locus; court witnesses—including the defendants’ mother—confirmed the site is a footpath used by all, and neither party cross-examined them. Applying civil evidentiary standards and treating the counterclaim as an independent action, the court found the site a public access path. It condemned the defendants’ self-help, dismissed the counterclaim, and ordered a refund of GH¢450 for the blocks and GH¢700 costs to the plaintiff.