Try asking the following...
Try asking the following...
May 22, 2024
HIGH COURT
GHANA
CORAM
The plaintiff/Respondent herein issued a writ of summons against the defendant/Applicant at District Court Berekum claiming the follows relief. “Declaration that the unregistered private car (kia sportage) is the bonafide property of the plaintiff/Respondent as same does not form part of the estate of Emmanuel Awuah Adjei @ Kwabena Awuah Before I proceed further it must be noted that plaintiff/Respondent initially sued together with one Ameyaa Franklina against the Defendant/Appellant, however, the said Ameyaa Franklina managed to settle her issue with the said Defendant/Appellant and therefore filed notice of Discontinuance of her action against the Defendant/Appellant.
Meanwhile when the parties appeared before the District Magistrate Court, they were instructed to file their pleadings in the case which they complied.
Indeed, the Plaintiff/Respondent statement of claim could be briefly captured as follows; That before his uncle one Emmanuel Awuah Adjei who is now deceased died he promised to buy the plaintiff/Respondent a car, the subject matter of dispute in this appeal.
According to the plaintiff before then he used the said car during his marriage celebration and used it as a friend’s car.
That on 31st night of December, 2017 the plaintiff/Respondent who is a pastor told his congregants that his uncle has promised him to buy him a car so the congregants should assist him to thank his uncle the said Emmanuel Awuah Adjei.
After the plaintiff/Respondent further averred that it was his friend’s car Kia Sportage which his uncle promised to buy for him after seeing him using it during marriage celebration.
That the said car belongs to his church member Amankona Kelvin Agyei(PW2) who was selling the car at the price of GHc38, 000. 00 plaintiff also avers that his uncle gave him Ghc30, 000. 00 to make initial payment which he gave to PW2 that after paying the said Ghc30, 000 PW2 handed over the car to him but kept the car papers since he had not finished paying for the cost of the car.
Plaintiff/Respondent further says that later when he went to his uncle for the remaining GHc8, 000. 00 his uncle told him that he could not get the said Ghc8, 000. 00 and that since the car belong to him the Plaintiff/Respondent, he should go and looked for the remaining balance to pay the car owner.
Plaintiff therefore went for a balance of Ghc8, 000. 00 to pay PW2 therefore bringing the total and the final payment to Ghc38, 000. 00 and that when he paid the last Ghc8,
AI Generated Summary
Pastor Frank Awuah, nephew of the late Emmanuel Awuah Adjei, sued in the Berekum District Court to declare a Kia Sportage his property. He testified that church member Amankona Kelvin Agyei was selling the car for GHc38,000, his uncle gave him GHc30,000 toward the purchase, and he borrowed GHc8,000 to complete payment. The certificate of purchase (Exhibit B) named Frank as owner, and he possessed the vehicle during Emmanuel’s lifetime. Emmanuel’s widow, the Defendant/Appellant, contended the car belonged to Emmanuel, cost GHc35,000, and was acquired for NDC chairmanship campaigning, with Frank merely driving it. The District Court found for Frank. On appeal, Justice Harry Acheampong‑Opoku struck out several legal‑error grounds for lack of particulars and considered only the omnibus ground that the judgment was against the weight of evidence. He rejected challenges to writ competency and title, applied evidentiary burdens and presumptions, credited Frank’s account including advancement of GHc30,000, and dismissed the appeal, affirming Frank’s ownership and that the car is not part of Emmanuel’s estate.