Try asking the following...
Try asking the following...
May 21, 1935
WEST AFRICAN COURT OF APPEAL
GHANA
CORAM
The following judgment was delivered:-
DEANE, C .. J.
This is an appeal against a decision of Strother-8tewart, .J. who gave judgment for defendants on a claim against them for damages for ". trespass in the years 1932 and 1933 on a portion of "plaintiffs' land situate at Cape Coast commonly known as " Prospect Hill which said piece or parcel of land is bounded on all " sides by plaintiffs' land being part of Prospect Hill aforesaid" and for an injunction.
The plaintiffs are Mr. P. A. Renner a practitioner in this Court of over fifty years standing and his wife; the defendant Annan is the person who claims to have bought the piece of land aforedescribed in the year 1904 and to have been in possession of it ever since; and the other defendants are his agents and servants who have acted under his orders.
A trespass to land is an entry upon land or any direct and immediate interference with the possession of land. The comprehensive way of describing a trespass is to say that the defendant broke and entered the plaintiffs' close and' did damage, and it follows that in order to maintain an action for trespass the plaintiff must have a present possessory title-an owner of land who is legally entitled to possession not being competent to maintain an action for trespass before entry (Wallis v. Hands, 1893, 2 Ch. 75). "Where indeed both parties are in a field claiming possession the possession being disputed, trespass will be at the suit of that one who can show that the title is in him-but that so far as I have been able to follow the evidence is not the case here. As we have seen the writ is for trespass to a specific portion of land, which is said to be surrounded by other parts of plaintiffs' land known as Prospect Hill; the evidence shows clearly that the contest is about a parcel of land 64 x 110 which came into the possession of defendant in 1904 and of which he has been in possession from that time up to to-day-and the fact that plaintiffs were later put into possession of adjoining land even if it surrounds the defendants' land does not enable them to say that they are in possession of the piece of land with regard to which the trespass is alleged. The plaintiffs' remedy was in my opinion by an action for ejectment if he could not get possession of this parcel of land and the action for trespass will not lie.
Suppose however I am wrong in this view of the "facts and the law applicable to them, and that it be held that plaintiffs' possession of adjoini
AI Generated Summary
On appeal from StrotherStewart, J, Deane, C.J. dismissed the trespass action brought by Mr. P. A. Renner and his wife against J. E. Annan and Annans agents over a defined parcel at Prospect Hill, Cape Coast. Annan had possessed the 647110 plot since 1904. Deane, C.J. explained that trespass requires present possession; plaintiffs later possession of surrounding land did not confer possession of the disputed parcel, making ejectment the proper remedy. Alternatively, with possession disputed, plaintiffs bore the onus to prove title and to succeed on the strength of their own title. Plaintiffs failed to produce key documents (Mary Barness will, the plan referenced in the 1905 mortgage, and a later instrument Renner executed in favor of his wife and children), leaving uncertainty over who held the mortgaged moiety. The court therefore dismissed the appeal with costs; Kingdon, C.J. and Werber, C.J. concurred.