ALFRED KWABENA ASIEDU v. JUDICIAL SERVICE OF GHANA & 2 ORs
March 26, 2026
COURT OF APPEAL
GHANA
CORAM
- GIFTY DEKYEM (MRS), JA (PRESIDING)
- LYDIA OSEI MARFO (MRS), JA
- DR. RICHMOND OSEI-HWERE, JA
March 26, 2026
COURT OF APPEAL
GHANA
CORAM
Try asking the following...
This appeal raises the question whether failure of the Judicial Council Disciplinary Committee to notify the appellant in writing about the disciplinary charges preferred against him before the commencement of the disciplinary hearing constitutes a substantial breach of the rules of natural justice that renders the entire disciplinary proceedings a nullity. It also raises questions about the propriety of the findings of the Disciplinary Committee that led to the dismissal of the appellant – whether the findings can be said to be ultra vires and/or an error of law patent on the face of the record.
The appeal is from a decision of the High Court (Industrial and Labour Division), Accra. The court refused to quash the proceedings and/or findings of the Judicial Council Disciplinary Committee that led to the dismissal of the appellant herein as a Circuit Court Judge. The said ruling of the High Court is dated 5th July, 2024.
The background facts leading to this appeal are devoid of controversy. Appellant was removed from office by 2nd respondent as a Circuit Court Judge in a letter dated 13th November, 2023. This was as a result of the findings of a disciplinary committee that was set up by the Judicial Council to investigate a petition received from one Singari Diana Sadia against the appellant.
Before the disciplinary committee was established, the Director of the Complaints Unit of the Judicial Service wrote to the appellant to respond to the petition and the appellant obliged by filing a response. The petition, together with the appellant’s response, was reviewed by a Justice of the Court of Appeal, who recommended that the matter be referred to the Judicial Council. The Chief Justice (2nd respondent herein) referred the matter to the Judicial Council. The Judicial Council subsequently established the disciplinary committee with the mandate to investigate the complaint against the appellant.
The Judicial Council Disciplinary Committee, after its hearings and deliberations, found that the appellant misconducted himself as a judge for having what it termed an “inappropriate relationship” with the said Singari Diana Sadia, who had appeared before him in a divorce matter at the Jasikan Circuit Court. The disciplinary committee also found that the appellant abused his power by maliciously prosecuting the petitioner. The disciplinary committee therefore, r
AI Generated Summary
The Court of Appeal considered the dismissal of Alfred Kwabena Asiedu, a Circuit Court Judge at Jasikan, following a Judicial Council Disciplinary Committee inquiry triggered by a petition from Singari Diana Sadia. The committee invited Asiedu after he had responded to the petition; it heard multiple witnesses and concluded he had an improper relationship with the petitioner, abused his power by instigating her arrest and prosecution, and committed malicious prosecution. The Judicial Council adopted the report, and the Chief Justice removed him for stated misbehaviour by letter of 13 November 2023. On judicial review, the High Court refused relief, finding adequate hearing and treating malicious prosecution as inconsequential. On appeal, the Court of Appeal majority held there was no breach of natural justice merely because the invitation lacked formal charge particulars since Asiedu had actual notice and was heard. However, the Committee acted ultra vires by finding “inappropriate relationship” beyond its terms, and its malicious prosecution determination was a patent error of law while the criminal case was pending. As abuse of power and impropriety hinged on that unlawful finding, the majority set aside the High Court’s decision and ordered certiorari to quash the Committee’s report and the removal letter.