ABDUL FATTAH ALAWA v. REBECCA AZAGLO & ANOR
April 4, 2023
DISTRICT COURT
GHANA
CORAM
- HIS WORSHIP NELSON DELASI AWUKU
Areas of Law
- Evidence Law
- Civil Procedure
April 4, 2023
DISTRICT COURT
GHANA
CORAM
Try asking the following...
INTRODUCTION/BACKGROUND:
Per a Writ of Summons and an amended Statement of Claim filed on 6th January, 2023 the
plaintiff claimed against the defendant as follows;
a. An amount of GH₵50,000.00 for disconnecting of electricity to his room.
b. Cost.
CASE OF THE PLAINTIFFS
The plaintiff stated that he is a tenant in the house of the 2nd defendant Kwame Azaglo.
The plaintiff stated that the 1st defendant is the daughter of the 2nd defendant and that
there are two meters in his rented house, one used by the Land Lord and the other by the
tenants.
The plaintiff stated that the meter for the tenants is controlled by the 1st defendant who
keeps the bills and shares same when necessary.
The plaintiff stated that during the lock down as a result of the Covid 19 pandemic, a bill
was generated for the house by the Electricity Company in the absence of the tenants
because they had both left for Kumasi and Keta respectively.
The plaintiff stated that whiles away he received a call from the 1st defendant who
informed him that the bill amount brought for the period of March to July 2020 was
GH₵450.00 and that the light to the house has been disconnected as a result so he is to
pay an amount of GH₵150.00.
The plaintiff stated he subsequently agreed with the 1st defendant to pay an amount of
GH₵100.00 instead of the initial GH₵150.00 because he is not always around and
consumes less electricity.
The plaintiff stated that he paid GH₵70.00 instantly to the 1st defendant and later sent her
the balance of GH₵30.00 through Mobile Money and few days later the 1st defendant
called to inform him that the line to their house had been reconnected.
The plaintiff stated that he travelled and upon his return from Kumasi on the 28th of
March, 2021 noticed there was no light in his room which caused him to sleep in the
darkness until the following day but when he confronted the 1st defendant about the
development she demanded that he pays the outstanding GH₵50.00 before his room
could be granted access to power.
The plaintiff stated that he demanded from the 1st defendant to produce all bills for the
period to verify her claim but she failed but when one of the tenants Margaret brought
out the bills, they realized that the entire bill for March to July, 2021 was GH₵388.00 and
not GH₵450.00 as the defendant earlier stated so there were no outstanding arrears owed
to the Electricity Company of Ghana.
The plaintiff stated that the 1st defendant refused to h
AI Generated Summary
This landlordtenant dispute arose in Ghana between a tenant and his landlord, Kwame Azaglo (2nd defendant), and the landlords daughter (1st defendant) who managed electricity bills for tenants. The plaintiff sought GH50,000.00 in damages and costs, alleging his rooms electricity was disconnected after he paid GH70 and GH30 toward a bill the 1st defendant initially quoted as GH450.00, and that the disconnection caused business losses in his gamewildlife trade because he could not charge his phone. Defendants maintained the relevant accumulated bill was GH408.28 (shared GH388.28), that plaintiff owed GH50, and denied a GH100 agreement. Applying the Evidence Act standards and principles on admissions, the court found the 2nd defendant ordered the disconnection. However, the claimed losses were special damages that were not strictly proved, and the plaintiff failed to mitigate. The court dismissed all reliefs and awarded costs of GH1,000 to the defendants.