ABA AMOKUMAH VS KOBINA KUM & HANNAH ARTHUR
April 22, 2024
HIGH COURT
GHANA
CORAM
- LORDSHIP JUSTICE JOHN-MARK NUKU ALIFO “J”
Areas of Law
- Property and Real Estate Law
- Probate and Succession
April 22, 2024
HIGH COURT
GHANA
CORAM
Try asking the following...
INTRODUCTION The fundamental question raised for the determination in this appeal involves the nature and ownership at customary law of a piece of land on which the deceased husband of the Plaintiff who died intestate built a house numbered KK66 at Kokoado.
Whilst the 1st and 2nd Defendants maintain that the land belonged to their grandmother/mother respectively and thus assumed the nature of a family property, the Plaintiff on the other hand insists that her late husband acquired the property from Nana Kow Ansah, Chief of Dompoase Kokoase who is the rightful owner of the land.
This is an appeal against the Judgment of Her Honour Mawusi Bedjrah sitting at the District Court, Elmina delivered on 5th September, 2022. Naturally dissatisfied with the decision, the Plaintiff/Appellant registered her protest against the decision of the by filing a Notice of Appeal on 1st December, 2022 consisting of 3 grounds.
Brief Facts The facts that gave rise to the instant appeal are Plaintiff/Appellant (hereinafter called the “Appellant”) was that the wife of the deceased who was also the uncle and brother of the 1st and 2nd Defendants (hereinafter called the “Respondent”)respectively.
1st Defendant was appointed the customary successor of the Plaintiff’s husband after his demise.
According to the Appellant, the Respondents have taken over a 2. 0-acre orange plantation and a 1. 0-acre palm plantation which she jointly developed with her deceased husband some 15 years ago on land acquired from the Chief of Dompoase Kokoado, Nana Kow Ansah.
She further claims that a three-bedroom residential building numbered KK66 developed on a plot of land in the Kokoado township jointly acquired with her late husband from the same Nana Kow Ansah has been taken over by the Defendants.
The Defendants vehemently denied the Plaintiff’s claim and rather submitted that all the properties in contention including the plantations and land on which the house is situate are family lands originally acquired by their Great-grandmother from one Nana Kweku Mensah over a century ago.
On the 24th day of November, 2021 the Appellant commenced the instant action against the Respondents for the following reliefs: The Plaintiff claimed against the Defendants jointly and severally the following reliefs: (a) Declaration of title to that piece or parcel of orange plantation land situate, lying and being at Kokoado, in the Komenda district of the Central Region of the Republic of Ghana containing an appro
AI Generated Summary
This Ghana High Court appeal concerned competing claims over two plantation parcels and a house, No. KK66, in Kokoado, Komenda District. The widow of the deceased, Samuel Arthur, maintained these were self‑acquired properties granted by Chief Nana Kow Ansah of Dompoase Kokoado and jointly developed with her husband; she sought declarations of title, possession, proceeds, rent, and return of chattels. The Defendants—Arthur’s nephew (1st Defendant and customary successor) and brother (2nd Defendant)—asserted that the lands, including the house plot, were family property originally acquired by their great‑grandmother from Chief Nana Kweku Mensah over a century ago. After the District Court granted declarations and possession of the plantations, return of chattels, damages and costs, but not rent for KK66, the Plaintiff appealed. The High Court, per Justice John‑Mark Nuku Alifo, found insufficient proof of root of title for the house land, upheld customary law principles that improvements on family land become family property, rejected a capacity challenge by recognizing the spouse’s beneficiary capacity, dismissed the appeal, and affirmed the lower court’s judgment with costs.