Rafaelova v District Court Bratislava (Slovakia)
2014
ADMINISTRATIVE COURT
UK
CORAM
- MR JUSTICE OUSELEY
Areas of Law
- Criminal Law and Procedure
- Human Rights Law
2014
ADMINISTRATIVE COURT
UK
CORAM
AI Generated Summary
An appeal was dismissed against the extradition decision made by District Judge Blake for a 40-year-old female Appellant to be returned to Slovakia. The Appellant's pickpocketing offence, committed in December 2007, was considered serious and organised. Although her family circumstances were examined, no hardship was identified. With no valid grounds for appeal, the extradition order stands.
J U D G M E N T
MR JUSTICE OUSELEY: This is an appeal against the decision of District Judge Blake ordering the extradition of the Appellant, a 40 year old female, to Slovakia to serve a sentence of imprisonment in connection with a conviction.
The offence in question was described as robbery, although it appears that, in reality, it is a pickpocketing offence carried out in December 2007. She was present at her trial. The Appellant has confirmed her criminal tendencies in her time in the United Kingdom where she has committed similar further offences and has been sentenced to imprisonment.
The District Judge considered her family circumstances carefully. No particular issues of hardship were raised. She had come to the country as a fugitive. In the absence of sufficient circumstances suggesting hardship to the family, the District Judge's decision was that there should be extradition.
The Respondent's skeleton argument summarises that the offence is relatively serious. It is clearly an organised piece of pickpocketing. The Appellant was a fugitive. There is a substantial time to be served. She has continued to offend and there is no particular family issue.
Mr Attlee has sought to come off the record this morning, which I have refused. He is unable, rightly, to advance any ground of appeal.
Accordingly, this appeal is dismissed.