Eskwai logo
Verify now as a student, judge or newly called lawyer for access to discounted plans.

Mohun -Smith v TBO Investments Ltd

2014

QUEEN’S BENCH DIVISION

United Kingdom

CORAM

  • HIS HONOUR JUDGE SEYMOUR QC

Areas of Law

  • Civil Procedure
  • Evidence Law

AI Generated Summary

His Honour Judge Seymour QC considered TBO Investments Ltd’s application under CPR 39.3(5) to set aside a judgment entered on 30 June 2014 after the company failed to attend the first day of trial. Before that hearing, Shakespeares (formerly on the record) had sent the listing office a letter from David McLaughlin enclosing a MED3 ‘Statement for Fitness to Work’ for Scott Robinson, TBO’s co‑director and key witness, citing stress and seeking an adjournment. The judge proceeded under CPR 39.3, struck out the defence and entered judgment for the claimant. On the set‑aside application, Robinson filed witness statements and Dr Adams of My Health issued brief letters confirming he was not fit to attend in the week commencing 30 June. Applying Court of Appeal guidance (Pereira; Ketley) and Norris J’s criteria (Levy), the judge found the medical evidence inadequate, stress alone insufficient, and that TBO did not act promptly given knowledge by early July and Robinson’s subsequent work and travel. The application was dismissed.