Try asking the following...
Try asking the following...
November 5, 2014
COMMERCIAL COURT
United Kingdom
CORAM
Judgment
Mr Justice Hamblen :
Introduction
The Claimants apply for an order under CPR Rule 81.4 , that the 4 th , 5 th , and 6 th Respondents (Mr Kashyap, Mr Anand, and Mr Duggal respectively) each be committed to prison for civil contempt of court for breach of a worldwide freezing order (“the WFO”), and for permission to issue writs of sequestration against all the Respondents (although the applications against the 2 nd and 7 th Respondents were not maintained at the hearing).
The WFO was granted by Teare J. on 16 May 2014 (“the Teare J. Order”), varied by Andrews J. on 23 May 2014 (“the Andrews J. Order”) and continued by Simon Rainey QC (sitting as a Deputy Judge of the High Court) on 9 June 2014 (“the Rainey Order”).
The Claimants contend that the 1 st and 3 rd Respondents (“Resources” and “Shipping” respectively) have failed to provide adequate disclosure of documents and information in accordance with Paragraph 10 of the Teare J. Order and paragraph 10 of the Rainey Order. They further contend that Resources has also disposed of its assets in breach of paragraph 3(2) of the Teare J. Order by funding the legal expenses of the 2 nd Respondent (“Group”).
The 4 th - 6 th Respondents are (or at the material times were) directors and officers of one or more of the Defendant companies. Specifically:
Mr Kashyap was, and still is, a director of Resources, who supplied such information as was given in response to the Teare J. Order by Resources
Mr Anand and Mr Duggal were directors of Group and of Shipping, and still are directors of Group. Shipping is now in liquidation in Singapore. Mr Anand and Mr Duggal supplied such information as was given in response to the Teare J. Order by Shipping.
The evidence relied upon by the Claimants mainly consisted of the 5 th affidavit of Mr Perrott and the 2 nd affidavit of Mr Staples and the exhibits thereto. The evidence relied upon by the represented Respondents (Group, Mr Duggal, Mr Anand and Mr Bhatia) mainly consisted of the affidavits of Mr Duggal, Mr Anand and Mr Bhatia and the exhibits thereto. Mr Duggal’s lengthy affidavit took issue with a number of fundamental issues relating to the 1 st Claimant’s claim and the basis upon which the WFO had been sought or obtained. However the Court’s orders stand unless and until they are set aside, which they have not been. Nevertheless in so far as Mr Duggal’s affidavit deals with background matters of relevance to the present applications I have to proceed on the a
AI Generated Summary
Four claimants—IPartner, Classic, Cockett, and Louis Dreyfus—obtained and enforced a worldwide freezing order against Panacore Resources DMCC, Panacore Group Pte Ltd, and Panacore Shipping Pte Ltd, alleging cynical asset stripping through write‑offs of substantial debts owed to Resources. The WFO, granted by Teare J., varied by Andrews J., and continued by Simon Rainey QC, imposed enhanced disclosure duties. The claimants sought committal of directors Mr Rishi Anand, Mr Sunil Duggal, and Mr Vikram Kashyap for civil contempt, and writs of sequestration. Mr Justice Hamblen held that Shipping and its directors did not commit contempt: their disclosure was provided to the best of their ability within tight deadlines, with proper enquiries made of key personnel and reliance on Singapore proceedings and bank statements, and there was no continuing duty to search. Conversely, Resources and Mr Kashyap made no attempt to comply with the later Rainey Order and were found in contempt, given a final 14‑day period to purge the contempt, and warned that imprisonment is a real possibility if non‑compliance continues. The alleged disposal of assets to fund Group’s legal fees was not proved, and CPR service and procedural requirements were satisfied.