Eskwai logo
Verify now as a student, judge or newly called lawyer for access to discounted plans.

THE STATE v. BROBBEY AND NIPAH

1962

SUPREME COURT

CORAM

  • VAN LARE
  • OLLENNU
  • AKUFO-ADDO JJ.S.C

Areas of Law

  • Criminal Law and Procedure
  • Evidence Law

AI Generated Summary

Van Lare J.S.C., writing for the Supreme Court, allowed appeals by two men convicted by a Kumasi High Court jury of murdering Kwame Nsonamoah at Sekodumasi on 22 July 1961. The Court recounted that Nsonamoah was found bleeding on his store verandah with pellet holes nearby and later died from gunshot‑induced skull fracture and brain laceration. The prosecution relied entirely on circumstantial evidence, notably taxi driver Kwasi Kankam’s account of transporting the appellants to the village, hearing gunshots, and observing a dismantled shotgun and cartridge disposal. A co‑accused’s police statement (exhibit M) alleged the first appellant ordered the second to shoot; however, the Court emphasized this statement was inadmissible against the appellants. It held the trial judge misdirected the jury by treating exhibit M as if it were evidence against all and by instructing on “common purpose” without admissible proof, rendering the convictions unsafe. The Court quashed the convictions and entered acquittals.

JUDGMENT