SANDAH v. ASANTE AND ANOTHER
July 17, 1970
HIGH COURT
GHANA
CORAM
- ABBAN J
Areas of Law
- Civil Procedure
- Administrative Law
July 17, 1970
HIGH COURT
GHANA
CORAM
Try asking the following...
JUDGMENT OF ABBAN J.
This application is brought under Order 34, r. 2 of the Supreme [High] Court (Civil Procedure) Rules, 1954 (L.N. 140A), asking for an order staying certain proceedings that are now pending before the Lartebiokorshie District Court Grade I, until the present suit now pending in this court is heard and determined.
Counsel for the applicant, Miss Ayisi, argued with all seriousness, that if the action in the said district court is allowed to proceed, it will prejudice the applicant's claim which is before this court, since the claim in the district court as well as the claim in this court involves similar points of law. Learned counsel for the applicant further submitted that the goods that are the subject-matter of the dispute before the Lartebiokorshie District Court were wrongfully seized by the respondents at the Ghana-Togo border, from the custody of the applicant's bailee, who is now one of the two defendants in the action proceeding in the said district court. Counsel therefore contended that any decision against the bailee by the said district court, will affect the applicant's claim before this court. Counsel further argued that the action before the Lartebiokorshie District Court is quasi-criminal and that if the decision goes against the applicant's bailee, it is likely the goods may be confiscated. Counsel therefore submitted that it is necessary that the proceedings in the Lartebiokorshie District Court should be stayed.
In opposing the application, counsel for the respondents contended that the goods were never seized from the applicant, but that they were lawfully seized from Jash Adebayo and Moro Sandah who are the defendants in the case before the Lartebiokorshie District Court. Counsel said these two persons attempted to cross the Ghana-Togo border in a vehicle No. KC 5001 with those goods which are worth over N¢76,000.00 without an export licence; conduct which is contrary to the Customs Ordinance, Cap. 167 (1951 Rev.). Counsel for the respondents further [p.16] submitted that the action before the said district court was instituted and that the hearing actually started some sixteen days before the writ of summons in the present action was issued, and that in any case proceedings under the Customs Ordinance enjoy precedence over all other proceedings and that the application for stay should not be entertained.
Before considering the submissions of both counsel, I will like to look a little closer at the rule unde
AI Generated Summary
Abban J. considered an application by an applicant seeking to stay proceedings pending in the Lartebiokorshie District Court Grade I while a related suit proceeded in the High Court. The application, brought under Order 34, r. 2 of the Supreme [High] Court (Civil Procedure) Rules, 1954, argued that the district case raised similar legal points and, because it was quasi‑criminal, could lead to confiscation of the goods seized at the Ghana–Togo border from the applicant’s bailee. Respondents maintained the goods were lawfully seized from district court defendants Jash Adebayo and Moro Sandah, who attempted the border crossing in vehicle KC 5001 with goods worth over N¢76,000.00 without an export licence, contrary to the Customs Ordinance; the district case had begun sixteen days before the High Court suit. The court held Order 34, r. 2 pertains only to High Court proceedings and cannot stay district court actions. The court declined to invoke inherent jurisdiction absent oppression or vexation, noted the issues in the two fora differ (customs licensing vs. ownership/wrongful seizure), and emphasized section 234 priority for customs proceedings. The application was dismissed with N¢20.00 costs to respondents.