ROCKSHELL INTERNATIONAL LTD. v. WAHOME STEEL LTD.
2004
COURT OF APPEAL
GHANA
CORAM
- ARYEETEY, J.A. (PRESIDING)
- ANINAKWAH, J.A.
- QUAYE, J.A
Areas of Law
- Tort Law
- Evidence Law
- Civil Procedure
- Property and Real Estate Law
AI Generated Summary
Rockshell International Limited sued Wahome Steel Ltd for delivery or replacement of a building and equipment at Lawlawvor and damages for conversion, alleging that in June 1995 their plant yard was burned and heavy equipment gas‑cut and removed to Wahome’s premises. Rockshell had imported equipment for the Keta Sea Defence Project and later stored and hired it from Lawlawvor. Wahome defended on the basis of an explicit authorization from the Shai Traditional Council, headed by Nene Martey Chartey Awah III and acting through Nene Okuampa Korabo IV, to flame‑cut and collect scrap at Lorlorvor‑Shai for tonnage‑based purchase. The High Court awarded substantial damages and interest relying on replacement values and pro forma invoices. On appeal, Aryeetey J.A. found Rockshell failed to prove with verifiable evidence the identity and value of the items allegedly destroyed or appropriated, highlighted inconsistent documentation and timelines, noted testimony that earlier fires had occurred and that persons seen loading metal in June 1995 were not from Wahome, and concluded there was no evidentiary basis to hold Wahome liable. The Court of Appeal allowed the appeal and set aside the judgment and costs.