Eskwai logo
Verify now as a student, judge or newly called lawyer for access to discounted plans.

MICAH v. BRUCE

1970

HIGH COURT

GHANA

CORAM

  • TAYLOR J

Areas of Law

  • Civil Procedure
  • Property and Real Estate Law

AI Generated Summary

Taylor J in the High Court entertained an interlocutory appeal arising from a District Court Grade I rent and ejectment suit. The respondent landlord sued the appellant tenant for N¢653.40 arrears and eviction. The appellant, represented by counsel, irregularly filed an affidavit and later a so‑called amended statement of defence containing a counterclaim for N¢600 damages for breach of a verbal tenancy agreement, alleging removal of windows. Shortly before opening the defence, counsel sought to amend the counterclaim to N¢1,500 and then argued lack of jurisdiction and asked for transfer to the circuit court. Indignant, the magistrate reviewed his earlier order granting the amendment, restored the original N¢600 counterclaim without hearing the parties, refused adjournment, and directed the matter to proceed. On appeal, Taylor J held the review violated audi alteram partem, emphasized district court summary procedure and counterclaim requirements, concluded the counterclaim exceeded jurisdiction and should have been struck out, set aside the ruling, and allowed the appeal without costs.

JUDGEMENT