Eskwai logo
Verify now as a student, judge or newly called lawyer for access to discounted plans.

KOFI MUNKO OF ABUANU v. E. T. K. ASSIMEH OF ACCRA

1948

HIGH COURT

GHANA

CORAM

  • Quist, J

Areas of Law

  • Civil Procedure

AI Generated Summary

Quist, J considered two consolidated appeals from judgments of the Agona Native Court “B” arising out of the same transaction involving plaintiffs Kofi Munko and Kobina Idan against defendant E.T.K. Assimeh. In each suit, the plaintiffs moved to join Ohene Kojo Amuakwa of Agona Duakwa as co‑defendant; Assimeh opposed, but Amuakwa’s representative, Okyiami Kweku Kyirem, did not object, and the Native Court ordered joinder. The appellate court scrutinized section 39 of the Native Courts (Colony) Ordinance No. 22 of 1944, holding that only the person to be joined may apply and that written notification of the joinder order must be personally served. The plaintiffs’ applications and absence of service were not mere irregularities and could not be waived, as confirmed by Smurthwaite v. Hannay. The court rejected reliance on English misjoinder rules and Order 40 discretion, finding the defects affected the entire proceedings. It set aside the proceedings and judgment, remitting the case for retrial and awarding costs to Assimeh.

JUDGMENT