Eskwai logo
Verify now as a student, judge or newly called lawyer for access to discounted plans.

BONSU AND ANOTHER v. BONSU

1971

HIGH COURT

GHANA

CORAM

  • TAYLOR J

Areas of Law

  • Civil Procedure
  • Tort Law

AI Generated Summary

Taylor J. considered a rare procedural application by Osei Bonsu, Junior and Timber and Transport Co., Ltd. to join Popular Merchants Co., Ltd. as a third defendant to a defamation suit filed by Osei Tutu Bonsu. The libel claims stemmed from a 22 February 1971 suspension letter, a 30 March 1971 letter threatening summary dismissal, and an April 1971 Pioneer newspaper notice declaring Bonsu no longer employed by Timber and Transport Co., Popular Merchants Co., and Bantama Electric Bakery Co. The defendants admitted writing the letters, pleaded qualified privilege, and justified the allegations with detailed stock and payment discrepancies linked to Popular Merchants Co., then counterclaimed and argued joinder would avoid multiplicity and enable a counterclaim. Analyzing Order 16, rule 11, Taylor J. applied Lindley and Devlin tests and rejected jurisdiction where an interveners presence is unnecessary to adjudicate the libel issues, dismissed unspecified embarrassment, reaffirmed that plaintiffs cannot be compelled to join co-tortfeasors, and refused joinder, awarding N30.00 costs to the respondent.

JUDGMENT