Eskwai logo
Verify now as a student, judge or newly called lawyer for access to discounted plans.

BENDA v. AWUKU

1978

COURT OF APPEAL

GHANA

CORAM

  • JIAGGE
  • KINGSLEY-NYINAH
  • ANNAN JJ.A

Areas of Law

  • Contract Law
  • Civil Procedure

AI Generated Summary

This appeal concerned a building contract under which the contractor agreed to finish the owner’s house for ¢21,555 but failed to complete the works by late 1971. The owner, in protective custody during much of 1972–1973, later hired another contractor in February 1974 who completed the job by June 1974 for ¢10,000. At trial, the judge awarded ¢10,800 for loss of use over one and a half years and ¢1,000 general damages for inconvenience, plus costs of ¢1,500. On appeal, Annan J.A., writing for the court, accepted findings that the owner intended personal occupancy rather than letting and emphasized that contractual damages are compensatory and require proof of actual pecuniary loss. He declined to adopt rental value as a uniform measure for loss of use in domestic occupancy cases and disallowed the special damages entirely. General damages for non-physical inconvenience were recognized but reduced to ¢500 because they appeared influenced by ‘uncomplimentary conduct.’ Costs were reduced to ¢500, leaving a final award of ¢3,725, with the builder receiving costs on appeal.

JUDGMENT