Try asking the following...
Try asking the following...
April 22, 2024
HIGH COURT
GHANA
CORAM
This is an application for and on behalf of the defendant/applicant hereinafter referred to as applicant praying the Court for an order granting leave to the applicant to amend the statement of defence.
I shall quote the relevant paragraphs as follows: 4. That upon service of the writ of summons together with the statement of claim, the applicant entered appearance and statement of defence through their lawyer.
5. That the thrust of the respondent’s case is that they were one of the donors that gave out land to the applicant and therefore entitled to recognition and compensation as done to the others by the defendant.
6. Upon documents obtained at the time the applicant instructed its lawyer, it admitted the position claimed by the plaintiff even though it contended that it was an irrevocable gift.
7. That a further scrutiny of the document revealed that the then Headmaster who admitted the grant was deceived.
8. That I attach the original document concerning the grantors of the land.
9. That the acknowledgement was due to fraud perpetuated on the applicant.
PARTICULARS OF FRAUD a. Intentionally and falsely representing that the family was one of the grantors of land to the defendant.
10. That in view of this discovery, it has become necessary that the true position of the real donors be settled.
11. That I attach herewith the proposed amendment.
The plaintiff/respondent hereinafter referred to as respondent opposed the application.
I shall quote the relevant paragraphs as follows: 2. I sued the defendant/applicant claiming the reliefs endorsed herein.
5. I have been advised by my lawyer and verily believe same to be true that parties are bound by their respective pleadings and the amendment the defendants are seeking to effect offends the said rule.
6. I have been further advised by my lawyer and I again believe same to be true that though parties are allowed to amend their respective pleadings such amendments have their limits and the kind of amendment applicant is seeking does not fall under any of the amendments allowed.
8. I deny paragraph 7 of the affidavit in support and state that the two documents attached by the defendant/applicant to their affidavit in support have at all material time been available to the defendants and they could not have instructed their lawyer differently.
As such plaintiff has attached one of those documents to his witness statement which has already been served on the defendant/applicant as an exh
AI Generated Summary
This case involves an application by the defendant, E.P. Secondary School (the applicant), seeking leave of the Court to amend their statement of defence. The plaintiff/respondent had sued the school claiming to be one of the donors who gave land to the school and sought recognition and compensation. Initially, the school admitted this claim in their statement of defence, though contending it was an irrevocable gift. However, upon further scrutiny of documents by the current headmaster, particularly a document titled 'ACQUISITION OF THE LAND IN VOLTA REGION', it was discovered that the plaintiff's family was not among the original grantors of the land. The applicant alleged fraud, claiming the former headmaster was deceived into making the admission. The respondent opposed the application, arguing that the amendment would offend the rule against departure from pleadings and that parties are bound by their pleadings. Justice Joan Eyi King, after considering the submissions of both parties and relevant case law, granted leave to the applicant to amend their statement of defence. The Court held that the purpose of amendment is to enable the court to determine the real questions in controversy between the parties. Since evidence had not yet been adduced, the amendment would not contradict evidence already given and would bring pleadings in line with evidence yet to be led. The Court also granted leave to the respondent to amend their Reply and Witness Statements if any.