Eskwai logo
Verify now as a student, judge or newly called lawyer for access to discounted plans.

192046 SGT INUSAH KARIM v. THE REPUBLIC

2021

COURT OF APPEAL

GHANA

CORAM

  • ADJEI JA.
  • OWUSU-OFORI J.
  • ASARE-BOTWE (MRS.) J.

Areas of Law

  • Criminal Law and Procedure
  • Evidence Law
  • Administrative Law

AI Generated Summary

Sergeant Karim Inusah of the Ghana Armed Forces, stationed at the 37 Military Hospital, appealed his General Court Martial conviction and dismissal after refusing to vacate Senior NCO Block D Room 1, which Unit Part One Orders had allocated to Staff Sergeant Issifu Razak. The Command Sergeant Major, Ex‑WO Azuma Sylvanus, ordered Inusah to vacate by noon; he refused and was forcibly evicted, biting S/Sgt Alandu Emmanuel in the process. The Court Martial convicted him of disobedience of lawful command (s22, Act 105) and conduct prejudicial to good order and discipline (s54(1)), acquitting him on the violence count (s23). On appeal, Owusu‑Ofori J held PW3’s command was lawful under Armed Forces Regulations and the Armed Forces Act, rejected arguments that such orders were merely administrative or unconstitutional, and affirmed the sentence of dismissal as proportionate within the statutory scale, noting his prior disciplinary record and gratuity paid. Adjei JA concurred, stressing the Evidence Act’s burden of proof and finding no substantial miscarriage of justice; Justice Asare‑Botwe agreed. The appeal was dismissed.

JUDGMENT