Eskwai logo
Verify now as a student, judge or newly called lawyer for access to discounted plans.

ATSU v. THE REPUBLIC

July 29, 1968

COURT OF APPEAL

CORAM

  • OLLENNU
  • AZU CRABBE
  • APALOO JJ.A

Areas of Law

  • Criminal Law and Procedure
  • Evidence Law

AI Generated Summary

Ollennu J.A. delivered the judgment of the Court of Appeal in a case arising from a jury conviction for murder in the High Court at Kumasi. The appellant, a mason from Atonsu near Asukwa, was reported by a co-tenant for threatening to kill him; a police constable came to escort the appellant to the station. After refusing to go, the appellant suddenly attacked and struck the constable with a hammer and also struck a carpenter who arrived at the scene. The constable died the next day. Before trial, the judge observed the appellant’s abnormal behaviour and ordered psychiatric evaluation. A defence psychiatrist testified—unchallenged—that the appellant was mentally ill for twelve weeks and might have believed he was doing right while doing wrong. Despite clear directions on insanity and the special verdict, the jury convicted of murder. Invoking paragraph 13(1) and 14(4) of N.L.C.D. 84, the Court of Appeal held the verdict unreasonable, quashed the death sentence, substituted a special verdict of guilty but insane, and ordered detention as a criminal lunatic.

JUDGMENT