Eskwai logo
Verify now as a student, judge or newly called lawyer for access to discounted plans.

ADAI v. ANANE

November 13, 1972

HIGH COURT

GHANA

CORAM

  • OSEI-HWERE J

Areas of Law

  • Alternative dispute resolution
  • Civil Procedure
  • Property and Real Estate Law
  • Evidence Law
  • Tort Law

AI Generated Summary

Justice Osei‑Hwere allowed the defendant’s appeal from a District Magistrate Grade II, Bechem decision that had declared the plaintiff owner of the disputed land and awarded ¢100 damages. The plaintiff had sought declaration of title, possession, and ¢300 damages for trespass, relying on proceedings before the odikro of Bredi involving boundary owner Kwame Missa. The defendant pleaded res judicata based on a customary arbitration presided by Nana Duayaw‑Nkwantahene and conducted at the Duayaw‑Nkwanta Traditional Council, which the magistrate had treated as a nullity. On appeal, the judge held that “standing by” estoppel was misapplied, mere inaction could not bind the defendant, the Bredi proceeding was either not proven as an arbitration or was vitiated by the odikro’s interest, and the Traditional Council arbitration bore all hallmarks of a valid, binding customary arbitration. Upholding estoppel per rem judicatam, he set aside the lower court’s judgment and costs and entered judgment for the defendant with ¢80 costs.

JUDGMENT